A manager asked to approve an unusual payment needs more than a signature authority check. The decision may involve a personal interest, incomplete financial information or a company already struggling to meet its debts. The useful questions are what authority exists, what information supports the decision and what record will explain it later.
Lawyers in Dubai can help directors assess those questions before a disagreement becomes a personal claim. A company loss does not automatically become a director’s debt. However, separate incorporation does not remove responsibility for a personal guarantee, fraud or a proven breach of the duties applicable to the individual.
Federal Decree Law No 32 of 2021 on Commercial Companies recognises separate corporate personality and contains different provisions for different company forms. An LLC manager, a public joint stock company director and a free zone company officer should not assume that identical rules govern their positions.
The current framework includes amendments introduced by Federal Decree Law No 20 of 2025. Review the current legislation rather than relying on an old incorporation guide. The Ministry of Economy and Tourism publishes both the company law and the amendment.
Articles 3 and 5 address free zone companies and their activities outside the zone, with qualifications for matters governed by specific zone rules. Identify the place of incorporation, licence, branch arrangements and applicable regulatory regime. The job title on a business card may not explain the legal position.
Collect appointment documents, constitutional documents, powers of attorney and relevant resolutions. Record when the individual began and ended each role and whether they also acted as shareholder, employee, guarantor or actual decision maker.
Read signature blocks and operative clauses together. A contract signed for a company and an undertaking to pay personally raise different issues. If a bank or supplier requests a guarantee, assess its wording, amount, duration and release conditions before signing. Ask what would release the individual from the undertaking after leaving employment.
Article 83 addresses the powers of LLC managers and acts binding the company when the relevant capacity is stated, subject to restrictions in the applicable management documents. Article 22 requires an authorised manager to preserve company rights, exercise appropriate care and act within the company’s purpose and delegated powers.
For a significant transaction, identify who must approve it and whether approval must precede signature. Check the current version of the delegation and any limit on value or subject matter. Record the commercial reasons and supporting information alongside the approval.
Article 84 makes an LLC manager responsible to the company, partners and third parties for fraudulent acts. It also requires compensation to the company for losses or expenses resulting from misuse of powers, breach of applicable law, the company’s memorandum or the manager’s appointment contract, or gross error. Conflicting exclusions in the relevant documents are void.
The assessment should therefore identify the conduct alleged, the applicable duty, the loss and the connection between them. An unsuccessful expansion is not analysed in the same way as a payment to an undisclosed personal business supported by false invoices.
Article 162 separately addresses liability of public joint stock company directors and executive management for fraud, abuse of authority and violations of law or the company’s articles. Article 84 also applies director provisions to LLC managers subject to the LLC rules. Counsel should explain the relevant interaction instead of treating every management claim as identical.
Tell the relevant decision makers about a connection with a proposed supplier or other counterparty. Provide enough information to understand the interest and follow the applicable approval process. A commercially attractive price does not remove a disclosure requirement.
For public joint stock companies, Article 150 requires disclosure of a conflicting or shared interest in a transaction submitted to the board, recording of the disclosure and abstention from voting. Article 152 regulates related party transactions, misuse of company information and competing activities. It does not impose a blanket prohibition on every related party transaction.
For LLC managers, Article 86 restricts managing a competing company or undertaking competing or similar business without general assembly approval. Breach can support removal and compensation. Review outside appointments and business interests before accepting them, particularly where customers, staff or confidential information overlap.
Minutes should identify the information considered, questions raised, approvals and objections. If the records do not reflect an objection accurately, raise the discrepancy promptly through the appropriate process. Do not create a retrospective account that disguises what actually happened.
Under Article 162, directors opposing a majority decision are protected from responsibility for that decision where their objection is recorded in the minutes. Absence alone is insufficient: the statutory test addresses lack of knowledge or knowledge coupled with inability to object. The provision does not excuse separate misconduct by the individual.
Preserve complete emails, financial reports and electronic approvals. The federal Evidence Law recognises electronic evidence and addresses its production. Retaining the underlying files and their context is more useful than relying only on selected screenshots when a decision is challenged.
Prepare reliable cash flow information and a list of debts, security and commitments. Ask what assumptions support continued trading and whether proposed payments or asset transfers prejudice creditors. Obtain advice before distributing assets or preferring connected parties during financial difficulty.
Federal Decree Law No 51 of 2023 provides the financial restructuring and bankruptcy framework, with exclusions including entities governed by specified special regimes. Article 15 addresses applications when payment has stopped or available information indicates likely inability to pay debts at maturity. Article 240 also requires company approvals for applications within its scope.
After a company is declared bankrupt, Article 246 permits the Bankruptcy Court, on a qualifying application, to order specified managers, directors or other responsible persons to contribute an amount proportionate to their fault towards company debts. It concerns defined conduct during the two years before payment cessation. A shortfall in assets should not be presented as automatic personal liability for every director.
The law also contains criminal provisions. Article 271 provides criminal penalties, where a final bankruptcy judgment has been issued, for specified conduct including inadequate accounting records and intentionally incorrect information. Financial difficulty, civil liability and criminal liability require distinct analysis.
The DIFC Courts reported 117 Civil and Commercial Division claims with a total claim value of AED 2.6 billion in 2025. These figures describe that division's caseload, rather than the number of director liability claims or amounts recovered. They provide commercial dispute context without establishing personal responsibility in any particular company.
Identify who is making the claim and whether the alleged loss belongs to the company, a shareholder or a third party. Preserve the relevant documents and deadlines. Prepare a chronology separating personal involvement from decisions taken by others, and supply unfavourable records as well as supportive ones.
Ask lawyers in Dubai whether the company and individual need separate representation. Their interests can diverge even where the company pays the fees. Federal professional legislation restricts conflicting representation and requires written fees and a defined engagement. Clarify who the client is and which work is authorised.
Review any relevant management liability insurance promptly, including notification conditions, exclusions and control of the defence. Check the advisers’ registration through the Dubai Legal Affairs Department directory, while recognising that the directory does not certify specialisation or endorse a provider.
No. Identify a separate legal basis, such as a personal undertaking or established liability for relevant conduct. The company’s legal form, documents, applicable legislation and facts matter. A demand addressed to a manager does not by itself establish that the manager owes the amount personally.
Not necessarily. Article 162 contains a specific test concerning knowledge of the decision and the ability to object. A properly recorded objection can be important, but the relevant circumstances and any separate conduct must still be examined.
Give lawyers in Dubai the incorporation records, appointment documents, authority limits, disputed contracts, minutes, financial reports and correspondence. Explain personal guarantees and connected business interests. Include any claim notice, regulator enquiry or imminent payment decision so that urgent issues can be assessed first.
Keep the relevant authority, approval, supporting financial information and commercial explanation with the payment record. Identify any personal connection that required disclosure and record how it was addressed. A clear contemporary record helps advisers assess the actual decision without treating every later loss as proof of a breach.
Confirm who the adviser represents, what work the engagement covers and how personal involvement will be assessed. Provide appointment dates, authority limits and any personal undertakings. Where interests differ, ask how separate advice will be arranged before assuming that the company's response also addresses the individual's position.
Dr. Hassan Elhais is a Senior Legal Consultant at Amal Al Rashedi Lawyers and Legal Consultants in Dubai. He advises on UAE family, civil, commercial and criminal law matters.
اتصل بنا
اتصل بنا
